A couple who bought a detached house in Be'er Ora, in the Arava paid the full price, but the contractor refused to hand it over until they signed a waiver of all claims in exchange for ILS 60,000. The court held this was coercion, cancelled the waiver, and awarded them late-handover compensation, a refund of construction-cost index linkage and compensation for distress.
What happened
The couple bought a house for almost ILS 2 million, with a contractual handover date of 21.3.2022. Construction started late: on the contractual handover date only the floor slab had been poured. The occupancy permit was issued in December 2022, and the house was connected to electricity only at the end of that month.
In negotiations over compensation, the contractor's lawyer wrote that if no agreement was reached, 'the apartment will be sold to someone else'. The couple transferred the entire balance, ILS 264,562, and asked to schedule the handover. The contractor replied that the house would be handed over only after they signed a settlement: ILS 60,000 in compensation and a waiver of all claims. The couple were living in temporary housing and their son was already enrolled at a school near the new house, so they signed on 1.2.2023 and received the keys. They then sued.
The waiver was cancelled
The court held that the contractor 'held the house hostage': it had all the money and refused to hand over the house without a signature. An oral understanding between the lawyers did not bind the buyers themselves, who had not agreed to the amount. Under a guiding ruling of the Beer Sheva District Court, which the Supreme Court declined to hear on appeal, a waiver a buyer signs in order to receive the home is not valid. Even without that ruling, the circumstances here amounted to coercion. The contractor could have handed over the house and placed the ILS 60,000 in trust until the dispute was decided.
The compensation
- Late handover: the contract predates the amendment to the law, so the contractor is exempt only if it proves circumstances beyond its control that it could not foresee. It did not call the engineer or any relevant witness. The delay runs until the actual handover, because the house was not connected to electricity or fit to live in, and the contractor itself delayed it by demanding the signature. Compensation was based on rent of ILS 8,000, as set by the buyers' appraiser, against whom the contractor filed no opposing opinion: 1.5 times for eight months and 1.25 times after that, ILS 119,500 in total. After deducting the ILS 60,000 already paid, about ILS 74,000 remains in today's value.
- Construction-cost index linkage: most payments fell due after the contractual handover date only because the contractor built late. The court called linkage during the delay 'a reward to the defendant that was late' and ordered a refund of about ILS 35,700.
- Distress: ILS 15,000.
- Mortgage interest: the claim for the higher mortgage cost was dismissed.
In total the contractor must pay ILS 124,700, plus ILS 30,000 in legal fees, the court fee and the cost of the expert opinions. In setting the legal fees, the court also took into account the contractor's 'aggressive negotiation'.
Key takeaways
- A contractor cannot make handing over the home conditional on signing a waiver of compensation; a waiver signed under such conditions may be cancelled.
- If the contractor refuses to hand over without a signature, document it in writing, pay the balance 'under protest' and keep all correspondence.
- An agreement between lawyers does not bind you unless you approved it yourself.
- If the contractor was late, you may be able to recover construction-cost index linkage you paid during the delay.
- The calculator on this site lets you check what you are owed under the version of the law that applies to your contract.
This article summarizes a published Israeli court decision in plain language and is not legal advice. Every case depends on its facts. The parties' names have been omitted. This is a first-instance decision and may be appealed.


