Adv. Shlomo Yehoshua LeviAttorney and certified mediator 050-3400420
Insurance

The insurer paid for only part of the car damage, and the court ordered it to pay the rest

  • Court: Afula Magistrates' Court
  • Case: Case 10227-06-25
  • Decided 11.11.2026
  • Published: November 15, 2026

A driver who hit the car in front of him in a traffic jam was paid only for the damage to the front. According to the insurer's traffic examiner, the damage to the front-left corner did not come from that accident. The court held that the insurer had not proved it, and ordered it to pay the rest of the damage assessed by its own appraiser.

What happened

In heavy traffic on a bridge in Haifa, the driver bent down to pick up papers that had fallen. His car kept rolling and hit the vehicle stopped in front of him. When he looked up he turned the wheel to the right, and the two cars were dragged together a short distance. His car, covered by comprehensive insurance, was damaged at the front and the front-left corner.

The insurer's appraiser assessed the damage in three 'focal points': front, front-left and the right wing, about ILS 53,600 in total plus loss of value. The insurer paid only about ILS 9,700 for the front, after the deductible. It argued that the left-side damage was unrelated to the accident, relying on a preliminary report by its traffic examiner. The driver sued for the difference, about ILS 44,800.

What the court decided

  • The burden is on the insurer: a party claiming that part of the damage did not come from the accident, and that the insured is claiming for something else, must prove it. The insurer did not.
  • Credible testimony: the court believed the driver. The short account in his accident report does not contradict his detailed account at trial; the two fit together.
  • One continuous area of damage: the damage to the grille, bumper, headlight and left wing runs side by side. Even the insurer's appraiser agreed that such damage is normally treated as one focal point. Turning the wheel to the right explains the impact on the left.
  • Indirect damage on the right: the right wing was bent by pressure from the bonnet. The insurer gave no reason for not paying for it.
  • Loss of value: the insurer had not paid it, even for the front damage it did not dispute.
  • A late expert opinion: the insurer's opinion was filed three days before the hearing. The court preferred the driver's expert and ordered the insurer to pay ILS 1,500 in extra costs for the delay.

The outcome

The claim was accepted. The insurer must pay the full damage at the two unpaid focal points, the loss of value and the VAT it deducted from the appraiser's fee, plus linkage and interest. It also pays the court fee, the expert's fee and legal fees. In total, more than ILS 40,000 before interest and costs.

Key takeaways

  • An insurer that pays only part of the damage, claiming the rest is unrelated to the accident, has to prove that claim; it is not up to the insured to disprove it.
  • A preliminary traffic examiner's report is not an expert opinion. You can challenge it and file an opposing opinion.
  • Photograph the scene and both cars before they are moved. Those photos decided this case.
  • Received a partial payment? Check that loss of value, every focal point in the appraisal and VAT were all paid.
  • Object to a partial payment in writing and keep a copy. It strengthens your account in court.

This article summarizes a published Israeli court decision in plain language and is not legal advice. Every case depends on its facts. The parties' names have been omitted. This is a first-instance decision and may be appealed.

Phone next to an open notebook and glasses

Have a question? Start here.

Tell us briefly what it is about so we can prepare for the conversation.

050-3400420

The message opens in WhatsApp on your device. The site does not store what you write.

WhatsApp Call